Any young man who diligently searched the library at Monticello for nastiness could indeed find a few corners where it lurked, but dispassionate information on homosexuality would be hard to find. Jefferson’s personal feelings about same-sex relations were not recorded, but he did discuss briefly the legal aspects in his writings on law reform. He felt it was important that the law clarify two distinct crimes which had been conflated under the heading of buggery: sodomy and bestiality. Bestiality, he believed, should be decriminalized entirely. Because “it can never make any progress” (i.e. there was no possibility of pregnancy), bestiality could not cause any permanent injury to society and therefore should not be severely punished. Sodomy, of course, can never make any progress either, but Jefferson felt that it was enough of a threat to public welfare that it should remain a criminal offense. He did suggest, however, that the penalty be reduced from hanging to simple castration.
William Benemann, Male-Male Intimacy in Early America: Beyond Romantic Friendships
You are a complex man indeed, Mr. Jefferson.
(via publius-esquire)




